Casey was born and raised in upstate New York near Albany. He completed his bachelor's degree at Sage College of Albany in New York in 2016. During that time, he played D3 soccer and competed in the NCAA tournament his junior year. Following his undergraduate education, Casey completed his Doctorate of Physical Therapy degree at The Sage Colleges in Troy, NY in 2019.

He has also completed SFMA Level 1 and become a Certified Strength and Conditioning Specialist. In 2021, he moved to Virginia to pursue the Orthopedic Physical Therapy Residency Program program at Inova. Casey's physical therapy interests include ACL surgery, low back pain, ankle sprain, shoulder pain and return to sport/athlete recovery.

Casey enjoys playing with his dog Cali, watching sports especially soccer, being outside, trying new foods and beer and reading.